Skip to Content
Menu Toggle

I Hired a Competitor’s Employee and Got an Employee Poaching Lawsuit: What Happens Next?

Pen on a Non-Compete Agreement, illustrating an employee poaching lawsuit after hiring a competitor's employee

Reading Time: 7 minutes


An employee poaching lawsuit can name two defendants: the person you hired and your company. The former employer wants to stop that employee from working for you, and it may also want money from you. Your next steps are a response deadline, a possible injunction hearing, and a close look at what the employee brought along. Each depends on facts that a court has not yet examined.

What Happens First When Your Company Is Served?

A deadline starts running. In Florida state court, a defendant generally has 20 days to respond after service, and a missed deadline can lead to a default. Read the complaint for the claims against your company, and check whether a motion for a temporary injunction is already on file. The firm’s guide to the first 72 hours after service walks through the early steps.

Were you just served in an employee poaching lawsuit? Talk with a Jimerson Birr business litigation attorney before you respond to the former employer or discuss the case with the employee.

Why Is Your Company Being Sued and Not Just the Employee?

The former employer can plead claims against both of you. A non-compete or non-solicitation promise binds the person who made it. Florida’s restrictive covenant statute permits enforcement only against a person who signed the covenant in a writing, so claims against a new employer typically take a different form:

Does Hiring an Employee Who Signed a Non-Compete Make Your Company Liable?

Not by itself. In Fiberglass Coatings, Inc. v. Interstate Chemical, Inc., a summary judgment ruling, Florida’s Second District Court of Appeal held that a company that hired an employee, knowing his non-compete barred the job, was not liable for intentional interference through the hiring alone. Merely agreeing to employ him was not the same as inducing a breach.

The same case let a second theory continue: that the new employer induced the employee to solicit the former employer’s customers. Conduct after the hire can matter as much as the hire. One appellate decision does not settle your facts, and the elements are covered in the firm’s guide to what a plaintiff must prove for tortious interference.

What Must the Former Employer Prove to Enforce the Covenant?

It must clear several statutory hurdles before a court enforces anything. Under section 542.335, the former employer has to show:

  • A signed writing. The covenant must be in a writing signed by the person it is enforced against.
  • A legitimate business interest. The statute lists trade secrets, valuable confidential information, substantial customer relationships, customer goodwill, and extraordinary or specialized training. A covenant with no such interest behind it is void and unenforceable.
  • Reasonable necessity. The restraint must be reasonably necessary to protect that interest. Once the former employer makes a prima facie showing, the burden shifts to the party opposing enforcement to show the restraint is overbroad, overlong, or otherwise not reasonably necessary.

The statute also tells courts not to consider individualized hardship to the person bound. In deciding enforceability, your employee’s need for the job is not part of that analysis.

Can a Court Stop the Employee From Working for You?

Yes, if the former employer proves an enforceable covenant. Section 542.335 directs courts to enforce restrictive covenants by any appropriate and effective remedy, including a temporary injunction. A violation of an enforceable covenant creates a presumption of irreparable injury, and a temporary injunction requires a bond. See the firm’s injunction service page and its guide to what employers must show to enforce a non-compete.

Fees can run both ways. In an action to enforce or challenge a covenant, and absent a contract clause on fees, the statute says a court may award fees and costs to the prevailing party.

A narrower group of highly paid employees falls under Florida’s CHOICE Act. When a covered employer applies, the court must preliminarily enjoin a business from engaging the covered employee during the noncompete period. The business can modify or dissolve that injunction only with clear and convincing evidence, based on nonconfidential information, that the employee will not provide similar services or use confidential information or customer relationships, or that the business is not engaged in similar business activity. In an action to enforce that section, the prevailing party is entitled to reasonable fees. Whether an agreement qualifies depends on its terms and the employee’s pay, as explained in the firm’s CHOICE Act article.

How Can a Trade Secret Claim Reach Your Company?

Your company can face one even if no one at your company took a file. Florida’s Uniform Trade Secrets Act defines misappropriation to include using a trade secret when the user knew or had reason to know that its knowledge came through someone who owed a duty to keep it secret.

Remedies can include damages for actual loss and unjust enrichment. For willful and malicious misappropriation, a court may award exemplary damages of up to twice that award.

How the former employer builds this kind of case is laid out in the firm’s articles on proving a competitor stole trade secrets and suing a former employee who took a customer list. The firm’s trade secret misappropriation page lists attorney Charles Jimerson as a contact.

What Should Your Company Do Right Now?

Protect the record and stop anything that could add a claim.

  1. Calendar the response deadline from the date of service.
  2. Preserve everything: email, texts, devices, and the employee’s recruiting and onboarding communications. Do not delete anything.
  3. Do not use, forward, or open files from the former employer. Set them aside and tell counsel.
  4. Pause the employee’s contact with the former employer’s customers until counsel reviews the covenant.
  5. Route communications about the case through counsel, using the firm’s guidance on managing internal communications during a lawsuit and early defense moves.

Your company and the employee are both defendants, and your interests may not match. Raise that early with counsel.

What Should You Check Before You Respond?

These facts change the answer. Gather them before anyone files anything:

  • Whether the employee signed a written non-compete or non-solicitation agreement, and its dates, territory, and terms.
  • What your company knew about the agreement, and when, including offer letters and hiring emails.
  • What the employee brought to your company: files, customer lists, devices, or accounts.
  • Whether the employee has contacted or been assigned to the former employer’s customers.
  • What you promised the employee in writing, including any pledge to cover legal costs.

These facts decide the outcome, and an attorney needs to review them before your company responds.

Did the former employer already ask for an injunction? Request a free consultation so a Jimerson Birr attorney can review the complaint and the covenant with you.

How Can Jimerson Birr Help With an Employee Poaching Lawsuit?

If you hired a competitor’s employee and now face an employee poaching lawsuit, the firm’s lawsuit defense work includes defending business tort claims and employment lawsuits. Call (904) 389-0050 or request a free consultation. In Florida state court, the response deadline generally runs 20 days from service, so waiting leaves less time to answer the complaint and any injunction request.

Media Contacts

Charles B. Jimerson
Chief Executive Officer

Jimerson Birr welcomes inquiries from the media and will do our best to respond to your deadlines. If you are interested in speaking to a Jimerson Birr lawyer or want general information about the firm, our practice areas, lawyers, publications, or events, please contact us via email or telephone for assistance at (904) 389-0050.

subscribe to legal alerts

subscribe to our blogs

sign up now
we’re here to help

Contact Us

CONTACT US