Skip to Content
Menu Toggle

Subpoena for Business Records in a Lawsuit You’re Not In: What Florida Companies Should Do

Stack of manila folders overflowing with papers, illustrating a subpoena for business records sent to a Florida company

Reading Time: 7 minutes


A subpoena for business records can reach your company even when it is not suing anyone and no one is suing it. A customer, vendor, or former partner ends up in court, and your files become evidence. A nonparty has real rights, but the key ones depend on acting before the compliance date.

Do You Have to Respond to a Subpoena When Your Company Is Not a Party?

Yes, but responding does not mean handing over everything. A nonparty can object, ask the court to quash or modify the subpoena, and seek protection for confidential records. Ignoring a served subpoena without an adequate excuse can be treated as contempt of court under Florida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.410.

Did a subpoena just land on your desk? Talk with a Jimerson Birr lawsuit defense attorney before you collect or send anything.

What Kind of Subpoena Did Your Company Receive?

The type of subpoena sets your deadlines and options, so identify it first. A document-only subpoena, a deposition subpoena with a document request, and a subpoena from another state or a federal court follow different rules. For background on where they fit in a case, see our overview of discovery in business litigation.

A Document-Only Subpoena Under Rule 1.351

Rule 1.351 lets a party get records from a nonparty without taking a deposition. The requesting party must first notify every other party and wait 10 days (15 if the notice is mailed) before the subpoena issues. That notice is not sent to you, so the subpoena may be your first warning.

You may object at any time before production. If you do, the records are not produced under the rule, and the requesting party has to seek other relief. The subpoena can also let you mail copies, and you can require advance payment of reasonable copying costs. Production can be demanded only in the county where the custodian lives, the records are kept, or the custodian regularly does business.

A Deposition Subpoena With a Document Request

A subpoena can also command a records custodian to appear for a deposition and bring documents. Under Rule 1.410, you can serve a written objection to the document request within 10 days after service, or by the compliance date if that is sooner. If you object, the other side cannot inspect or copy those materials without a court order.

A Subpoena From Another State or a Federal Court

An out-of-state lawsuit reaches Florida through section 92.251, Florida Statutes. The other side submits its subpoena to the clerk in the county where the records are, the clerk issues a Florida subpoena, and Florida law governs service and any motion to quash or for a protective order, filed in that county. Our guide to issuing an out-of-state subpoena in Florida covers the requesting side.

Federal subpoenas follow Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 45. A written objection is due before the earlier of the compliance date or 14 days after service, and a motion to quash goes to the court where compliance is required.

If your company is named as a defendant instead, that is lawsuit defense work, and the clock is different. Start with the first 72 hours after a commercial lawsuit is served.

What Should Your Company Do in the First Few Days?

Treat the compliance date as a hard deadline and work backward from it. These six steps protect your records and your options while an attorney reviews what the subpoena demands.

  1. Calendar the compliance date and any shorter objection window that applies to your subpoena type.
  2. Confirm who issued the subpoena, who served it, which court it came from, and whether it reached your registered agent or someone else.
  3. Issue a written hold so nothing responsive is lost while you decide how to respond. Our litigation hold guide explains what to preserve.
  4. Identify the custodians and systems that hold the records, and note any electronic sources that are costly to reach. A records retention program makes this step faster.
  5. Send nothing yet, and keep internal messages about the subpoena short, because internal communications can become evidence.
  6. Review your insurance policies for any notice requirement.

Informal talks with the requesting lawyer about narrowing the requests are one option, best held after counsel has reviewed the demand. The firm’s business litigation attorneys, including Charles Jimerson, work on discovery in commercial disputes.

Can Your Company Object, Narrow, or Quash the Subpoena?

Yes. You can object in writing, ask the court to quash or modify the subpoena, or seek a protective order. A motion to quash or modify an “unreasonable and oppressive” subpoena must be made promptly, and no later than the compliance time stated in the subpoena.

Common grounds to raise:

  • Scope: Rule 1.280 limits discovery to nonprivileged information that is relevant and proportional to the needs of the case, so requests for every record from every department invite a narrowing request.
  • Burden: A person can object to electronic data from sources that are not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost, though a court can still order it for good cause.
  • Privilege: Communications with your lawyers made to get legal advice may be protected.
  • Confidential information: A person from whom discovery is sought can ask for a protective order for good cause, and a court can order that trade secrets or confidential commercial information be disclosed only in a designated way.
  • Disclosure limits: Records covered by a confidentiality agreement or a legal limit on disclosure need review before anything leaves your company.

Who Pays to Collect and Copy Your Records?

Not automatically the requesting party, but a court can shift the cost. When it decides a motion to quash, a court can condition denial on the requesting party advancing the reasonable cost of production. Hard-to-reach electronic data can carry a similar condition. Raise cost before you spend money collecting anything.

In federal court, an order compelling production must protect a nonparty from significant expense.

How Do You Protect Privileged Records?

Withhold privileged records by claiming the privilege, not by leaving documents out. Florida requires a party withholding privileged material to state the claim and describe the material without revealing it, and the federal subpoena rule imposes the same duty on the person subpoenaed. A nonparty should follow the same approach: list each withheld document and the privilege claimed.

Privilege protects confidential communications made to get or give legal advice, not the underlying facts or ordinary business records that already existed. Our guide to how privilege gets lost covers the common mistakes.

What Should You Check Before You Respond?

Five facts change the answer for your company:

  • The compliance date, and whether a shorter objection window applies.
  • Whether the subpoena came from a Florida court, another state, or a federal court.
  • Whether the requests reach privileged communications, trade secrets, or records covered by a confidentiality agreement.
  • Where the records live, how much there is, and whether any electronic sources are costly to reach.
  • Whether your company has any stake in the dispute beyond holding the records.

These facts decide what you must produce, what you can withhold, and who pays. An attorney needs to review them against the actual subpoena before anything leaves your company.

Not sure which of these facts applies to you? Request a free consultation with Jimerson Birr and bring the subpoena with you.

How Can Jimerson Birr Help With a Subpoena for Business Records?

If your company has received a subpoena for business records in a lawsuit it is not in, Jimerson Birr’s subpoena response work includes reviewing the subpoena, issuing litigation holds, weighing objections, a motion to quash or modify, or a protective order, and advocating for cost-shifting. Call (904) 389-0050 or request a free consultation. A motion to quash or modify must be made by the compliance time in the subpoena, so waiting can close that option.

Media Contacts

Charles B. Jimerson
Chief Executive Officer

Jimerson Birr welcomes inquiries from the media and will do our best to respond to your deadlines. If you are interested in speaking to a Jimerson Birr lawyer or want general information about the firm, our practice areas, lawyers, publications, or events, please contact us via email or telephone for assistance at (904) 389-0050.

subscribe to legal alerts

subscribe to our blogs

sign up now
we’re here to help

Contact Us

CONTACT US