Skip to Content
Menu Toggle

What Can a Landlord Collect When Suing for the Rest of a Lease?

Frustrated woman at a laptop with both hands raised, illustrating the question: landlord is suing my business, what now?

Reading Time: 6 minutes


A Florida landlord can collect only what the lease and the law allow. Without an acceleration clause, rent is generally owed only as each payment comes due. With one, the landlord may demand the remaining rent at once, but income from reletting the space must be credited against it.

Has your landlord already filed suit over the remaining rent? Talk with a Jimerson Birr lawsuit defense attorney before you answer the complaint.

Can the Landlord Demand Every Remaining Payment Now?

Generally only if the lease says so. In Hourglass Entertainment v. NRG Investments, Florida’s Second District Court of Appeal reversed the part of an award covering about four months of rent that had not yet come due, reasoning that the lease had no acceleration clause. The court affirmed the rest.

Read your lease for the clause before you accept the landlord’s math.

What If the Lease Does Have an Acceleration Clause?

The landlord may be able to claim the full remaining balance, but not a double recovery. In Horizon Medical Group v. City Center of Charlotte County, the court held that rent from any reletting during the remaining term must be credited against accelerated rent.

Whether a clause is enforceable as written, and how the landlord calculated the figure, are questions for an attorney reading your actual lease.

What Is Actually in the Landlord’s Number?

Ask for the ledger behind the figure. A complaint may combine unpaid rent to date, a claimed accelerated balance, late fees, and attorney’s fees. Each piece has its own basis in the lease, and each can be checked against it.

A single total hides which parts the lease actually supports.

Which Path Did Your Landlord Choose After the Default?

Florida courts describe three paths for a landlord when a tenant breaches before the lease ends, and the path chosen shapes what you can owe. The Hourglass court listed the paths:

  • Terminate the lease and retake the space for the landlord’s own account. The claim for future rent generally ends with the lease, though rent already owed and other claims may remain. We explain the landlord’s side in our post on whether a commercial landlord must mitigate damages.
  • Retake the space for the tenant’s account. The tenant stays liable for the shortfall between the rent and what the landlord can recover by reletting, and the landlord has a good-faith duty to mitigate. In Hourglass, the lease had no acceleration clause, and the court said it knew of no authority letting a landlord on this path recover future rent that had not come due.
  • Do nothing and sue as each payment comes due, or for the whole amount once it is due. The lease stays alive, and unaccrued rent is generally not recoverable unless the lease has an acceleration clause.

Which path your landlord took is a question of fact. A new tenant, a listing for the space, or renovations all bear on it. Ask in writing which path the landlord elected, because its notices and court filings can show it, and the answer affects every number above.

What Can Reduce or Defeat the Landlord’s Claim?

Several things can shrink the number, and none is automatic. Check each against the lease and the complaint:

For a broader view of tenant defenses, read our overview of commercial lease disputes and a Florida tenant’s remedies, and see our page on monetary and non-monetary lease defaults for how a default claim is framed.

Does a Personal Guaranty Change the Picture?

Yes. A guaranty makes the signer personally responsible under a separate contract, and it carries its own defenses. A landlord can name the company and the guarantors as defendants.

Read the guaranty itself: what it covers, who signed it, and when. Our posts on defenses to a personal guaranty in Florida and on being sued personally for a business debt cover the questions to ask.

Timing matters too. Florida generally allows five years to sue on a contract founded on a written instrument under section 95.11(2)(b), and a written lease or signed guaranty ordinarily fits that category, so check the dates on both.

What Should You Do in the First 20 Days After Service?

Start with the response deadline. Under Rule 1.140(a)(1) of the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, a defendant generally has 20 days after service to answer, and a missed deadline can lead to a default. Then work through this list:

  1. Confirm the date you were served, and count 20 days from it.
  2. Gather the lease, amendments, guaranty, default notices, rent ledger, and every message with the landlord.
  3. Document what happened to the space: when you left, whether the locks changed, and any new tenant or listing.
  4. Keep every email, text, and record. Delete nothing.
  5. Do not sign a surrender, payment plan, or settlement before an attorney reads it.

Our guides to the first 72 hours after service, a breach of contract complaint, and what a missed answer deadline means cover the pre-answer steps. Attorney James “Joby” Birr III has represented clients in commercial landlord/tenant disputes.

What Facts Decide How Much You Owe?

Five facts change the answer more than any others:

  • Whether the lease has an acceleration clause, and exactly what it says.
  • Whether the landlord retook the space, when, and whether it says it did so for its own account or yours.
  • Whether the landlord has relet the space or tried to, and at what rent.
  • Whether you or another owner signed a personal guaranty.
  • The date you were served and the dates of the missed payments.

These facts decide the outcome, and an attorney needs to review your lease, any guaranty, and the complaint before you respond.

Not sure which of these facts applies to your lease? Talk with a Jimerson Birr business litigation attorney about reading your lease and the complaint together.

How Can Jimerson Birr Help When a Landlord Is Suing Your Business for the Rest of the Lease?

If a landlord is suing your business for the rest of the lease, Jimerson Birr’s lawsuit defense team can review the lease, any guaranty, and the complaint, and defend your business against the claim. Call (904) 389-0050 or request a free consultation today. The 20-day response clock generally starts when you are served, and a missed deadline can lead to a default against your company.

Media Contacts

Charles B. Jimerson
Chief Executive Officer

Jimerson Birr welcomes inquiries from the media and will do our best to respond to your deadlines. If you are interested in speaking to a Jimerson Birr lawyer or want general information about the firm, our practice areas, lawyers, publications, or events, please contact us via email or telephone for assistance at (904) 389-0050.

subscribe to legal alerts

subscribe to our blogs

sign up now
we’re here to help

Contact Us

CONTACT US